Originally posted by X-height:
Its members or its ideals? There is such a thing as trying to correct your party and the way I see it: the greater number of Arnold-like Republicans that self identify then the power of religion and intolerance is offset. Whether you like Clinton are not you have to admit he was a check on the extreme of his party by letting moderate Dems know that they still have a home and that only they could fix it. Unlike you Canadians third parties aren't as viable here as I am sure you know so fixing the way to go.
However, Arnold wasn't saying "this is what we hope the Republican party will stand for or these are our ideas", he was saying "if you believe in this you are a Republican". Yet very few of these things truly stands for the Republican party (notice I say Republican party, not conservatives, which in my eyes is something completely different).
Originally posted by X-height:
1) Well, I'll tell you how. If you believe that government should be accountable to the people, not the people to the government, then you are a Republican.
A worthwhile goal, but not something that I see currently in the Republican party.
The Bush administration has hardly been "accountable to the people", which secret energy meetings or the PATRIOT ACT with secret courts. Maybe you can point out something that I missed, but personally I haven't seen anything that the Republicans have done to make the government more accountable to the people for their actions.
Originally posted by X-height:
2) If you believe that a person should be treated as an individual, not as a member of an interest group, then you are a Republican.
Once again, a worthwhile goal, but the Republican party is often pushed one way or another by interest groups and lobby groups such as the religious-right or the NRA. Once again, it's one thing to talk to talk, but something completely different to walk the walk.
Originally posted by X-height:
3) If you believe that your family knows how to spend your money better than the government does, then you are a Republican.
If you believe that your family knows how to spend your money better than the government does, then you are a Libertarian. While the Bush administration has given out tax cuts, they have not managed to cut spending, which means it's just future generations that are paying for current government expenses. However, I guess "If you believe that your kids should pay the bill for the current government years down the road, then you are a Republican" doesn't have the same ring to it.
Originally posted by X-height:
4) If you believe -- if you believe that our educational system should be held accountable for the progress of our children, then you are a Republican.
This is hardly a just a Republican value, as who doesn't believe the education system should be held accountable for the progress of the children?
Originally posted by X-height:
5) If you believe -- if you believe that this country, not the United Nations, is the best hope for democracy, then you are a Republican!
While I do admit that a current version of the Republican party has less trust in the United Nations than the Democratic party, I don't think either major party completely trusts the UN and is willing to let them have the last say in any international matter.
Originally posted by X-height:
6) if you believe that we must be fierce and relentless and terminate terrorism, then you are a Republican!
Once again, hardly just a Republican value. Unless I missed somewhere that the Democrats want to support terrorism? Not to mention there's been a lot of criticism over the Republicans ignoring terrorism while they went after Iraq and Saddam. Now Saddam has been captured while Osama bin Laden still runs free. Interesting enough while Saddam has been mentioned quite a bit at the RNC, I don't think that Osama bin Laden's name has not been mentioned and I doubt it will be.
Originally posted by X-height:
7) Now, there's another way you can tell you're Republican: your faith in free enterprise, faith in the resourcefulness of the American people, and faith in the U.S. economy.
Seems like another way to tell that you are a Libertarian. Of course the Bush administration is very much for free trade... except for softwood trade... and steel... and wheat... and...ah, what the hell, Bush is quite the projectionist! He may preach free trade but then completely ignores free trade agreements when it doesn't suit him. Canada has been trying with no luck to try to get him to honor the North American Free Trade Agreement with no luck. The WTO has ruled against the US in many of these cases (see
this link and
this link for two examples), but the US continues to ignore these rulings and continues to tack on tariffs. However, I'm not sure if Bush really believes in protectionism or if he's just trying to buy votes from areas that have a lot of these type of industries, or if these industries donate heavily to the Republican party (aka legal bribery).
And
that is why I said if you believe the Republican party actually stands for all those things, then you are gullible. Arnold was just throwing out rhetoric that did not resemble anything that the Republican party actually represents in reality.