This is why I should never toggle on ignored posts:
Jokergas: That never happened. The story is Dumy claims that on the DCMB JSA board Geoff Johns challenged him to a one on one debate. Mysteriously no one remembers this and the thread has vanished.
No. This is exactly what happened. Back when Geoff Johns still posted on the DC boards (before he stopped because they were "too negative" for him... meaning that people occasionally criticized his work), he invited me to talk to him about JSA at a con some day.
I think he was just trying to be polite.
Other posters were all like, "Yeah. You should say this stuff to his face."
And I said, basically, that I wasn't going to go to a con just to tell Johns to his face that I think JSA sucks.
That's all there is to the story.
Jokergas, naturally, twisted this around a few different ways and tried to make it sound like was more like a challenge to a duel or something. And then he started saying that I did meet with him in person (which never happened). And that basically, I was still pissed off because it didn't go well for me.
I don't know if I've ever been in the same state as Geoff Johns. There was no face-to-face confrontation or anything even remotely close to that.
Johns just suggested that I should talk to him at a con some time. There is nothing more to the story.
Of course, about half the time Jokergas went around telling people that my version of the story never happened. Because the thread got deleted back in, like, 2002 and he couldn't find it.
But that never stopped him from spreading his completely unverified version of a conversation on a thread he can't remember at any point over the last six or seven years.
Also, about the Zod bullshit... it was a lot more than two threads. I should know because I was actually there. Jokergas has the memory of a goldfish and should never be trusted about anything that he can't provide a link for.
Actually, he gets stuff wrong about half the time even when he has a link. Never listen to Jokergas about anything other than old comics and baseball. He doesn't remember what he said last week, much less what I was doing a couple of months ago.
Whoever Redskulldust is, he and all the Earth: Beer 30 posters can kiss my ass. They're all stupid trolls.