Actually, more people read the list than have ever taken notice of any aspect of Red Tall's existence. It was hotly debated on cartoonist websites that don't usually take note of the Journal, and was one of the Journal's most controversial ishs ever. Largely due to the major oversights of
1. No Cerebus,
2. Treating the entire Barks run on Donald Duck as one single entry, the entire Kirby/Lee FF run as a single entry, and every single panel or convention sketch by Los Bros. as a seperate work.
That aside, the issue's a great read.